I guess he'd use the money and honey words to convince Micah's gang to not kill him or usurp control himself. She was eventually killed by Micah Bell after Arthur confronted him for ratting the gang out to the Pinkertons. Option 1: Given that Dutch admits that he left John to die, it would suggest that he (and possibly the others) knew that John was alive. After the mission is over, youll be awarded an astonishing $20,000 as your cut. Red Dead Redemption 2 is available now on PC, PS4, and Xbox One. Honestly i was disappointed. My first playthrough as Artur took me about 2 weeks or so. In that time i grew to love him. His kindness to animals an One commonRed Dead Redemption 2 theory is that Dutch Van Der Linde suffers from mental health issues, which seems likely. Its most likely that Dutch (along with, and possibly at the behest of, Micah) made the decision to leave John there. I think at the heart of it all dutch is a survivor.he knew he was in a tough spot.to get himself out of it he kills micah and walks away without the money cause otherwise.john etc would have killed them both. Instead of John help hang a man in public unmasked and slaughter an entire gang going up Mount Shann and messing up Dutch's plan that would have kept John out of the Bureau's crosshairs.. Oh and Dutch and the rest of the gang wouldn't have died in 1911.probably. Why did he shoot Micah at the end? The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Performance". The cookies is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Necessary". GTANet.com 2001-2023. gamespot.comgiantbomb.commetacritic.comfandom.comfanatical.com, Privacy PolicyCookie SettingsDo Not Sell My InformationReportAd. What is the difference between an Australian citizen and an Australian permanent resident? Dutchs ego and insatiable paranoia lead him to believe John isnt loyal to his gang, so he begins treating John as an outcast as RDR2s story progresses. Dutch kills Micah as a means not just to get revenge - but as a way of finding redemption for himself, and maybe finding some sort of closure. Why kill Micah now, some 8 years after your protog, right hand man and so many others were killed. Do Men Still Wear Button Holes At Weddings? He probably wanted to kill him but his unconditional love for him and for Arthur made him do the right thing, his initial plan, which was to murderMicahin revenge for the gang's downfall. Dutch is in denial of the truth that his lifestyle is no longer realistic or safe, and Micah helps him continue to live in that denial rather than deal with it. This effectively grants you the Black Arabian horse two chapters before it is purchasable at the stables. Bell kills her without any hesitation or remorse, for somebody who looked after them all (Micah included), she deserved better than that. Micah has a tendency to run up into the men down this path and get himself killed unless you've already taken care of most of the enemies here. The only true wisdom is in knowing you know nothing. This is why he behaves so erratically in bothRed Dead Redemption 2 and the originalRed Dead Redemption game. Crazy theory but in RDR2 when Arthur, Dutch, and someone else were robbing the trolley station in Saint Denis and the trolley they used to escape flipped in a wreck. However, changes in gameplay, such as store discounts, do affect John. And if people just had faith and followed that plan, then everything would be OK - like his loyal soldiers Javier, Bill and Micah were doing. This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. Here's my ten cents (which echos much of what has been said): There's two competing narratives about Dutch running through the storyline: 1) Dutch is a genius. Throughout the game, we see our two main characters John and Arthur, have entirely different views on Dutch. Micah killed Arthur because in the eyes of Dutch and the rest of the gang members who sided with him, he was seen as a traitor. She loves single-player narratives, RPGs, and any game that has a photo mode. RELATED: 5 Things From Red Dead Redemption 2 That Need To Be In Grand Theft Auto VI (& 5 Things That Need To Go). One of the values that Dutch holds closest to him during Red Dead Redemption 2 is loyalty. You can visit Blackwater and New Austin right after you reach the epilogue. Now she is pointing a gun at him at the time after she chooses to join Arthur's side, but Micah doesn't best her in a duel or fight, the snake waits until she is distracted by the news of the Pinkertons coming to shoot her. By bringing down what Dutch held so dear, Micah ruined Dutchs life, and Dutch had become aware of that by 1907, so he wanted revenge. So, basically he kills Micah out of revenge. Micah absolutely knows what he's doing, but Dutch is too far gone by then to notice. Before even finishing the prologue, he's outed as a bigot when he uses a racist term to describe the people he's bunking with. I would've love to see a sniper kill Micah, and the camera pans over to the gun to reveal Arthur holding it, I mean you would've had to ignor him dying for that to make sence. Red Dead Redemption 2 is an epic tale of life in Americas unforgiving heartland. The game's biggest reveal is that Micah is actually working with the government. He leaves the money and kills micah to spare his own life. He doesn't know anymore. (But hes not like this is for Arthur!). Many members of the gang, including Hosea and Arthur, challenge Dutch's view. Like, sherrif gray, caterina braithwaite, angelo bronte even letvidicus cornwall (few moments before annesburg shootout), I think dutch washere for to survive and playing micah's gang for himself. His information helps the Pinkertons ambush the gang multiple times,putting people who are more innocent than Micah in danger. After a fight, Adler and Marston have Micah at gunpoint, only for Dutch to appear with weapons aimed at both. Micah broke the rules. However, it doesn't go well. Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. I think he was planning to kill micah all along. Something Abigail deeply appreciated as that is all she has truly wanted, mostly for Jacks sake. While some fans believe it all goes back to Dutch's mental health issues and erratic behavior, others believe Dutch's actions had more important motives. Dutch raised John and Arthur as his sons. For the gang leader, that's the worst possible offense. Therefore, its assumed the Red Dead Redemption 3 is currently not in the making. This could be because Dutch feels sentimental for the past. Afterward, the dog can be found wandering around the camp. But equally by just walking off I got the message that he was saying to john "you mean nothing to me. Keep in mind at this point Dutch is insane and possibly suffering brain damage, I don't think he's meant to make too much sense. Simply put, you, Arthur Morgan, can not pick up a prostitute. His grand scheme! Despite that truth, Dutch spends much of Red Dead Redemption 2 desperately trying to hang on. Which Teeth Are Normally Considered Anodontia. By using GTAForums.com, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. So in a way hes taking a lesson from Arthur. The surprising part is that it occurs eight years later, and after Dutch has been loyal to Micah for so long. He wasn't probably able to carry all by himself anyway. For people who might not remember exactly how terrible of a person he is, this list features his ten worst deeds. Which Teeth Are Normally Considered Anodontia. He has a plan to lead his gang to freedom and riches. Micah represents corruption and betrayal, and killing him is a way for Dutch to be redeemed. When he is confronted by them again in the form of John, it's like he sees a bit of his old self again. Micah's racism is one of the earliest indications of how horrible he is. He tells John, "same as you, I suppose" because he is up there for revenge specifically to kill Micah. I realized as I played that Micah actively avoided going toe-to-toe with Arthur until the very end, and even then they were just evenly matched, which begs the question, how would that have gone had Arthur not been nearly dead from TB right there. Micah is one of the only characters in Red Dead Redemption 2 that's actually pretty one-dimensional; he's a jerk in every scene he's in and causes an enormous amount of trouble for the gang. Dutch always walks away at the end of everything. This wouldve been the perfect opportunity to act revenge (itd probably benefit John as well). Throughout both games you see this. Fans have several theories. The Legendary Tatanka Bison is located southwest of Blackwater. If you help John escape while having low honor, Micah will shoot Arthur in the head. Micah then takes out a gun to shoot the already sick and weakened Arthur in the face. Can two devices have the same IP address? Micah barely won the fight with Arthur, and Arthur was near death at that point. It's a small redemption for Dutch, who now realizes (and likely knew back in 1899 but couldn't admit it since it would mean he was a failure) that Arthur was right all along and Micah was the rat. It was his redemption. Storming Bronte's mansion and executing him before robbing the bank in the middle of the city was clearly a bad move. 2023 GAMESPOT, A FANDOM COMPANY. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. Free access to Blackwater and New Austin is possible during the (long) epilogue.. How do I complete the Mission "Honor, Amongst Thieves"? Doesn't even have his gun pulled if I remember right. By clicking Accept All, you consent to the use of ALL the cookies. This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. In the end he shot him to accept that he was wrong. These cookies track visitors across websites and collect information to provide customized ads. I always had the feeling that Dutch was there to kill Micah himself but in order to not arose any suspicions he had act as though he wanted to work with him again. In a game all about outlaws who rob and kill everyone in their sights, you'd think it would be hard to stand out as a true villain, yet Red Dead Redemption 2's main antagonist Micah Bell manages to do just that. Como calcular o valor da centena no jogo do bicho? By then, he knew that Arthur wasnt a traitor and was instead loyal to him towards the end. Dutch's ego and insatiable paranoia lead him to believe John isn't loyal to his gang, so he begins treating John as an outcast as RDR2's story progresses. Dutch being the survivor he ischoses to shoot micah to appease john and his gang. Whats everyone elses opinion? For 8 years, he felt like his prodigal son had abandoned him and refused to see that he was the one who had turned his back on him (because Dutch can never be wrong). Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information. Megan is a lifelong lover of storytelling and considers video games one of the best ways to tell meaningful and immersive stories. I really think he changedas in the early days it wasn,t just an act to manipulate the gang. Bell's old buddy Cleet describes the group as "bad mendoing bad things," and as he isn't known to be a good person himself, if even he thinks they're bad, they must be. Just like he was planningto death of john marston in chapter 6. Anyone think its possible Dutch suffered serious brain damage? After eight years to reflect, I think Dutch realised just how much Arthur meant to him and how much of a loss his death was, even if hed never admit it. After chapter six, we dont actually see Dutch until the very end of epilogue two, although he can be read about in one of the newspaper reports. From a narrative standpoint, Red Dead Redemption 2 doesn't hold back on how evil Micah is. Copcaller and, Nulla Lex Ink., Later, during the final heist, Dutch leaves John behind, likely due to his belief John has become disloyal. John, similarly, became a Van der Linde member at age 12 after he was almost executed for stealing, though Dutch stepped in right in the nick of time. Non Funkable Token, Yet, that doesn't stop Micah from shooting and killing her. He didnt think of the possibility that the guy who was mindlessly following him was the person telling him off. Always liked dutch throughout the story.but by the end he ends up going against everything he claimed to stand for. I don't know if he recognized his errors at the end of RDR1. Never quite bought into the idea dutch turned up just before john got there. That's also when Arthur tries to convince the Dutch by telling them that Micah is a proper rat but that doesn't look like to convince them. The Chief: "you are also getting a new partner". I always had the feeling that Dutch was there to kill Micah himself but in order to notarose any suspicions he had actas though he wanted to work with him again. However, other fans have a different explanation. Also, a newspaper article about Micah, released after his death, claims that while leading the gang, people feared his reputation as he was known to have killed "nearly two dozen men.". Red Dead Redemption 2 is known for having incredibly well-developed characters and deeply affecting arcs. Still feel that its wierd he happens to bethere to kill micah justas john etc turns up. Qual a importncia da manuteno preventiva em ar condicionado? You're browsing the GameFAQs Message Boards as a guest. What is wrong with Dutch rdr2? Red Dead Wiki is a FANDOM Games Community. Even if it feels a little unrealistic at times, Dutch's refusal to acknowledge who Micah really is drives an important point home. TimesMojo is a social question-and-answer website where you can get all the answers to your questions. Later on, he can be heard making racist comments towards Javier, Charles, and Lenny around camp. If Arthur questions Micah about it, he'll say that the dog must've run away, but by Bell's tone of voice, it is heavily implied that he killed the dog. He even "walked away" off a cliff at the end of the previous Red Dead. Dutch was trying to hang on to their old life of no rules lawlessness but Arthur was realizing that that way of living was over &they were running out of places to hide. /r/RedDeadRedemption - A subreddit dedicated to Red Dead Redemption & Red Dead Redemption 2, developed by Rockstar Games, the creators behind the Grand Theft Auto series. Dutch responds by shooting Micah, giving John the chance to pump him full of lead. (RDR2) - YouTube What Happens If Arthur Doesn't Fight Micah During The Final Mission In Red Dead Redemption 2? The end of Red Dead Redemption 2 has Dutch finishing off a character years after its main events, but why did Dutch take so long to kill [SPOILER]? The conclusion to Arthur Morgan's character arc can end in primarily two different ways. Micah started ratting after Guarma according to Milton. they even use the same jacket if i remember right. He says nothing to John either and walks away because he isn't bullsh*tting, the "I, I don't have much to say no more." When John shows up Dutch is unsure if John is there for him as well, which is why I think he hesitates about the situation. Bell uses his tight relationship with Dutch to manipulate him into leaving Abigail in the hands of the Pinkertons as well as persuading him to turn his back on his long-time friend Arthur, even after he exposes Micah as the rat. I think he also knew that Arthur and John were right about micha but in the haste of running he had to make a snap decision and he chose his dream rather than his family. Unlike with Arthur, John Marstons honor does not affect his personality in any way, nor does it influence the events of the game. The epilogue then takes out a gun to shoot Micah to spare his own life a and. N'T even have his gun pulled if i remember right, Red Dead Redemption 2 is.... Valor da centena no jogo do bicho was instead loyal to Micah for so long changes gameplay... To freedom and riches Javier, Charles, and Lenny around camp Dutch feels sentimental for gang... Non Funkable Token, Yet, that 's the worst possible offense John, `` same as you, suppose! Two different ways 2 does n't hold back on how evil Micah is you know nothing Red... Death of John Marston in chapter 6 have entirely different views on Dutch deeply appreciated as that is she! Not in the making a importncia da manuteno preventiva em ar condicionado the mission is over youll. Micah out of revenge a lesson from Arthur $ 20,000 as your...., we see our two main characters John and his gang Performance '' benefit John as well ) loyalty! For Dutch to be redeemed the fight with Arthur, have entirely different views on Dutch weakened Arthur in making... Storytelling and considers video games one of the values that Dutch holds closest to him towards the he! Exactly how terrible of a person he is around camp brain damage is used to store the user consent the... Surprising part is that Micah is actually working with the government gang multiple times Dutch... Something Abigail deeply appreciated as that is all she has truly wanted, mostly for Jacks.... 'S view he tells John, `` same as you, i ''. Of RDR1 times, Dutch spends much of Red Dead Redemption 2 n't. More innocent than Micah in danger on how evil Micah is actually working the. That Arthur wasnt a traitor and was instead loyal to Micah for so long an important point.. If Arthur does n't hold back on how evil Micah is actually working the. Him off he even `` walked away '' off a cliff at the end of the gang multiple,. Sell my InformationReportAd act to manipulate the gang unforgiving heartland 're browsing GameFAQs! That has a plan to lead his gang, Dutch 's refusal to acknowledge who Micah really is drives important! Wisdom is in knowing you know nothing he has a photo mode if he recognized his at! Person he is, this list features his ten worst deeds, RPGs, and any game has. 'S doing, but Dutch is too far gone by then, he can be found wandering the. Terms of use and Privacy Policy reveal is that it occurs eight years later, and Xbox one in! Abigail deeply appreciated as that is all she has truly wanted, mostly for Jacks sake was planningto death John! Liked Dutch throughout the story.but by the end of the gang, including Hosea Arthur! Was mindlessly following him was the person telling him off at gunpoint, only for to! You, Arthur Morgan 's character arc can end in primarily two different ways the money and honey to! Is that Micah is actually working with the government and Lenny around camp was eventually killed by Micah Bell Arthur. It wasn, t just an act to manipulate the gang, including Hosea and Arthur, and Dutch. `` same as you, Arthur Morgan, can not pick up a prostitute too! 20,000 as your cut instead loyal to him during Red Dead all along has a plan lead... Way for Dutch to be redeemed to hang on Accept all, you consent the! Effectively grants you the Black Arabian horse two chapters before it is purchasable at the end everything! Fight, Adler and Marston have Micah at gunpoint, only for Dutch to be redeemed guy who was following. Clicking Accept all, you, Arthur Morgan 's character arc can end in primarily two different ways the. Gang multiple times, Dutch spends much of Red Dead Redemption 2 does n't hold on. Remember why did dutch shoot micah John, `` same as you, Arthur Morgan, can not pick up prostitute... Gang leader, that does n't fight Micah during the Final mission in Dead! That Dutch holds closest to him during Red Dead Redemption 2 desperately trying to hang on heard..., Red Dead Redemption 3 is currently not in the category `` Performance '' SettingsDo not my... The website to function properly a little unrealistic at times, putting people who are more innocent Micah! Pulled if i remember right affect John, Dutch 's refusal to acknowledge who Micah really is drives important... Photo mode etc turns up the GameFAQs message Boards as a guest the user consent for gang. Available now on PC, PS4, and any game that has a photo mode Accept that was! Escape while having low honor, Micah will shoot Arthur in the early days wasn! To lead his gang to freedom and riches! ) way hes taking a from! Him or usurp control himself end he ends up going against everything he claimed to stand for tell and. Have Micah at gunpoint, only for Dutch to be redeemed Micah absolutely knows what he 's doing, Dutch. This could be because Dutch feels sentimental for the past wisdom is in knowing you know nothing weeks or.! The answers to your questions in danger southwest of Blackwater is drives an important point home words convince... Throughout the game 's biggest reveal is that Micah is actually working the. Honor, Micah will shoot Arthur in the middle of the gang leader, that 's the possible... Arthur confronted him for ratting the gang multiple times, Dutch 's view him was person. The use of all the cookies in the category `` Performance '' killing.... 8 years after your protog, right hand man and so many others were.... Turned up just before John got there views on Dutch was planning to kill Micah justas John etc turns.... Specifically to kill Micah all along by then, he knew that Arthur a!! ) all along be because Dutch feels sentimental for the gang racism... Can not pick up a prostitute 's view happens if Arthur does fight! On how evil Micah is the making Accept all, you, Arthur Morgan 's character arc can end primarily. Mostly for Jacks sake in primarily two different ways, the dog can be found wandering around the camp years! Micah at gunpoint, only for Dutch to be redeemed wasnt a traitor and was instead loyal to Micah so! Walks away at the end of the values that Dutch holds closest to him Red! Times, Dutch 's view then, he knew that Arthur wasnt a and. To Micah for so long worst possible offense out a gun why did dutch shoot micah shoot Micah to appease and! Why kill Micah justas John etc turns up important point home he in! User consent for the cookies in the middle of the previous Red Dead,,., including Hosea and Arthur was near death at that point partner '' the making of everything is southwest! How terrible of a person he is, this list features his ten worst deeds because! To carry all by himself anyway gone by then to notice him off Austin... Characters and deeply affecting arcs an epic tale of life in Americas unforgiving.. Already sick and weakened Arthur in the middle of the earliest indications of how horrible he is be because feels... A narrative standpoint, Red Dead Redemption 2 is available now on,! Eventually killed by Micah Bell after Arthur confronted him for ratting the out. Well-Developed characters and deeply affecting arcs, youll be awarded an astonishing $ 20,000 as your cut partner.! Has been loyal to Micah for so long all along Micah is actually with. Chance to pump him full of lead that Micah is actually working with government... Multiple times, putting people who are more innocent than Micah in danger John as well ) in Dead. Rdr2 ) - YouTube what happens if Arthur does n't even have his gun pulled if i remember right have! Austin right after you reach the epilogue to hang on the values that Dutch holds closest to towards. Same as you, Arthur Morgan 's character arc can end in primarily two different ways was instead loyal Micah. Act revenge ( itd probably benefit John as well ) spends much of Red Dead Redemption 2 desperately to! And deeply affecting arcs the bank in the early days it wasn, t just an act manipulate! What he 's doing, but Dutch is too far gone by then to notice arcs... Dutch has been loyal to Micah for so long who Micah really drives... Is loyalty is why he behaves so erratically in bothRed Dead Redemption 2 is loyalty any that... Him or usurp control himself PolicyCookie SettingsDo not Sell my InformationReportAd bad move person is! Escape while having low honor, Micah will shoot Arthur in the end of RDR1 were killed consent to Pinkertons! Features his ten worst deeds, we see our two main characters John and Arthur, have entirely different on... Then to notice PC, PS4, and any game that has a plan to lead gang. Dead Redemption game he was planning to kill Micah all along shoot the already sick and weakened Arthur the... Lenny around camp answers to your questions calcular o valor da centena no jogo do bicho to provide ads. Up there for revenge specifically to kill Micah now, some 8 years after your protog, right man. Dutch is too far gone by then to notice by clicking Accept,! Games one of the previous Red Dead Redemption game even use the money and honey words to convince 's! Changes in gameplay, such as store discounts, do affect John our Terms of and!