On this point, its worth mentioning that the Ping i500 irons come in a blue dot version, which have more upright lie angles than the standard black dot version (featured in this comparison and the lie angle table above). Buttery soft feel on strikes out of the sweet sport. I think those irons are being replaced really soon, hence why they were left out of the test. The revised weight distribution creates optimal launch conditions, meaning that the ball launches high off the iron face without too much backspin. Some are closer to a players 3i. That meant going with T100 mid-and-short irons (6-PW), a T100S 5 iron, and a T200 4-iron. The M5 targets low and mid handicappers who want a more workable club with a thinner top line and a true players club feel, while the M6 is more of a game improvement club. The MP20 MMC irons are made with low to mid handicappers in mind (4-12), and they are slightly larger and have stronger lofts than the MP20 Blades. Just picked up the JPX 919 Forged with Steelfiber i95 shafts. Ive been playing the Callaway Apex for over a year now and they are great clubs but always looking for a little edge and I trust MGS. The Ping i500's are a slick classic blade design made for the superior golfers among us. amzn_assoc_marketplace = "amazon"; Free shipping for many products! Game improvement irons usually have fat soles that give you much less workability. Tungsten inserted in the mid and long irons, Not recommended for mid to high handicappers, Created in consultation with Louis Oosthuizen, Outstanding acoustics on strikes out of the sweet spot. The Max Impact technology in T200 irons means you get maximum speed from nearly any impact point on the face. As a group, they span a broad range of swing characteristics. I was hitting irons at my local Edwin Watts and fell in love with the Wilson D7s! Smaller numbers mean better consistency which will usually mean more than an extra yard or two on the golf course. Although we obtain their feedback, their subjective opinions do not influence, dictate or determine our testing rankings. with. But forgiveness is where the Titleist T200 irons shined. Its the best of both worlds. From our review, it is clear that Ping makes irons that best cater to the needs of mid and handicap golfers. Interesting. This leads to more repeatable distance from shot to shot. as well as honest reporting on the latest issues affecting the game I may have pointed out that some Touring Pros are using GI and SGI for the long irons to obtain distance and forgiveness instead of hybrids. A complete graphite shaft will cost you about $1,470. The T300 irons contain maximum impact technology, which helps the club generate maximum speed across the face, even on mishits. Dynamic Gold Shafts Reviewed Are They Any Good? Better players often prefer a thinner topline, and if you fall into this category, the T200's could look very good when you set them down at address. same overall performance and look really. While theres as much or more technology packed into Players Distance Irons as there is in the Game Improvement category, one of the distinguishing features of the category is is often a more compact, player-preferred profile. I will keep playing my Mizuno JPX 900 forged for now. #titleist #718ap3 #t200 I compare the new 2019 Titleist T200 Iron against the Titleist 718 AP3 Iron to see if the newer version is any better.See how an onli. Courtesy of Ping. Silver. These clubs are designed for mid handicappers who want more distance out of their irons coupled with forgiveness and a playable look and feel. I hit the C300 forged a while back and they felt amazing. The design is reasonably compact, with a topline that isnt too thin or too chunky. The leading feature is innovative face technology. Wilson D7 Forged Irons. If you swing way faster than the average golfer, spring for X-Stiff. The T200 features Titleists Max Impact Technology, which is meant to deliver faster ball speeds with better distance control and tighter shot dispersion. Most other irons seem to correlate between strokes gained and forgiveness. Each manufacturer features technology in the head designed for this purpose. GOLF120 Season2 #6 PING!! The 3-piece cavity badge enhances the feel of the iron. Matched To Your Swing. The irons further invoke a high apex, which helps you to achieve consistent carry and land the ball softly on the green. The club for which Strokes Gained values for the best shots are closest to the Strokes Gained value for the worst shots (relative to the field average) is the Most Forgiving. Titleist fans have every reason to be pleased with what the T200s have to offer. Titleist uses about 90g of Tungsten in the mid and long irons, which ends up being 1/3 of the weight of the club head and produces a higher MOI. A definite improvement over the AP3s. Golf Digest Team, The Titleist T200 irons are the successor to the AP3. Performs well in wet conditions and difficult lies, Medium clubhead profile is not suited to high handicappers. While there are always exceptions, if your handicap is above 10 and ball striking is not a legitimate strength, consider Game Improvement or Super Game Improvement. Repels water away from the clubface in wet conditions to insure clean contact. I love trying out new gear and this blog is where you can find all the gear I have tested over the years! Best way I can describe is dead. I think this category is going to be the future of golf. A:Absolutely. The forged face actually extends over the sole which is a godsend of a design for players having trouble with low-face strikes. Graphite shafts are typically for older players, or players with very slow swings. For distance, our critical metric is Total Yards. The Louis Oosthuizen Blue Prints beat out The T100s 95 to 93. Swing speed categories, to me, would be more helpful. Pings G Le 2 irons are a lightweight design built to deliver optimal swing speed for mid to high handicap women golfers. There is no hard number that makes you a mid handicap player, and the lines often get blurred between low, mid and high handicappers. An example of data being processed may be a unique identifier stored in a cookie. Minimal forgiveness on off-center strikes. Remember to keep an open mind and pay close attention to the shaft's influence on performance during your next fitting. If you fit either of these criteria, its definitely time for you to make the switch. Copyright 2023. They are all 4i already. Blade design; Forged maraging steel face; Muscle back appearance; Minimal offset; Precision-milled grooves; Hydropearl Chrome 2.0 finish; Key Features. Wilson are among the best clubs in the market. The MMC stands for Multi Material Concept, featuring a thin top line. Regular shafts work well for golfers who have slow to slightly below average swing speeds, and stiff shafts are for average to fast swing speeds. The Speed Bridge helps increase ball speed, and has been further improved from previous models. For myself, the Titleist fitter recommended a blend of three different iron models. Player distance irons are designed to look fairly similar to blades, but with a less intimidating profile. The Ping G425's have a much thinner face and top line than the Titleist t300's. The blade length of the Ping G425 irons is also slightly longer than the Titleist t300's. But offset is pretty much the same between both . The t200 is a club mid or low handicaps can play not too punishing not too forgiving just balanced. The irons hollow structure and forged, heat-treated, high-strength steel face insert allow for five times the bending of the face at impact compared to a cast iron. amzn_assoc_title = "Shop Related Products"; amzn_assoc_default_category = "All"; All in all I hit a few good shots with them and like I said I really wanted to like these, but overall I like the Apex better.. Im a scratch handicapper, I have played ( multiple rounds) with five of the sets you listed above the PXG Gen 3s. PING! Continue with Recommended Cookies. amzn_assoc_region = "US"; Out of curiosity, why werent the MP20 MCCs included? As technology advances, marketing increases and options multiply, it becomes critical to analyze distance and forgiveness in an iron. The hollow-blade construction partners with L-face inserts to deliver a high launch and soft landings. They felt comfortable and provided moderate greenside spin control. The large toe screw is visually offputting. Shorter blade lengths and thinner soles in irons like the. Delivers unwanted vibrations on heel and toe mishits. I have a hard time understand so many Pro:s went T200 with this amount of offset - unless they have some versions we don't see in retail. 5i, 6 iron, etc. Offering arguably the most balanced performance throughout the set, it's an iron that should definitely be on your demo list. A set of irons is an investment. When you stand over the i500s, you will be struck by how compact the face is, and you may also notice that they have minimal offset. This allows for higher flex, better ball speed and surprisingly great feel. While there is some overlap between categories, your search should begin with an honest assessment of your skill level (handicap) as well as what you need in your game. Make sure to check our more of our reviews, like our best rangefinder list that can help you nail more greens with confidence. However, these clubs offer limited workability for lower handicappers. If youre playing with a hybrid set of irons, or a general game improvement set that is more than a few years old, its time for you to upgrade to the latest golf club technology, as youre likely missing golden opportunities to shoot better scores through more accurate, longer, yet forgiving irons. To maximize distance, consider Cobra KING Forged Tec, Tommy Armour 845 ForgedorCallaway Apex 19. Hi, The perimeter tungsten weighting in the longer irons provided more stability and the Max Impact insert gave these irons a better . Our mission is #ConsumerFirst. Mizuno has become famous for producing irons with a buttery soft feel, resulting in a cult-like following from those who convert to the Japanese brand. amzn_assoc_search_bar = "true"; Added to the performance of the iBlades, is a buttery-soft feel on strikes out of the sweet spot, coupled with crisp acoustics. First are you low irons and your approach shots. . 9/17 date (assumed to be the release date). To help you understand these differences, we have highlighted the most important ones below. TaylorMade SIM 9.0*, Oban Kiyoshi Black 65 X. TaylorMade 300 Mini Driver 11.5*, Oban Kiyoshi Black 75 X. document.getElementById( "ak_js_2" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. As a result, they tend to be chunkier, and a bit less pleasing to the eye overall. On the other hand, game improvement irons tend to have large heads, a wide sole, and almost all the game improvement technology that an equipment manufacturer can offer. The results are in. You can generate nice ball speeds on the ultra thin face and the clubs are incredibly forgiving for high handicappers and beginners. Cavity backed irons are made to offer forgiveness on mishit shots, without losing any distance. Lastly, the ZX5s have a 1020 Carbon Steel body that absorbs vibration, improves acoustics and provides an extremely soft feel. com. Paired with a progressive set design that moves the CG lower in the long irons, the result is superior ball flight. MyGolfSpy accepts zero advertising dollars from any of the major golf manufacturers. If you are on the hunt for a new set of irons, I recommend testing the Ping G410 irons before making a final decision. The Titleist T200 were overall better to pick up and play with little learning curve. Also, thank you for your continual support! Holetheputt.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to products on Amazon. As mentioned earlier, the club faces feature the Max Impact polymer insert which are meant to increase ball speed at flex and improve sound and vibration dampening. IMO the P790 should be the prime benchmark for your players DISTANCE iron market. Ping I500 Irons. For example: This is 0.5 degress lower than the Ping G410 3 hybrid which has a standard loft of 18.5 degrees. The Ping i500 irons were pretty revolutionary when they first came out. Ping I210 Vs Titleist T200. The Tour V.T Sole is one of the most important design features of the ZX5s. NO ONE is buying these PING GOLF CLUB's anymore. Finally, the forged clubfaces wrap around the sole to ramp up ball speed on strikes off the lower part of the face. If you would like to change your settings or withdraw consent at any time, the link to do so is in our privacy policy accessible from our home page.. When an iron reasonably fits in more than one category, we defer to the manufacturers category choice. Silver. Thats over a third of the overall clubhead weight strategically positioned on the heel and toe for outstanding MOI. The clubs were crafted with less offset and a shorter blade, giving you the ability to achieve some shape on your shots. Id bet wilson is near top again. It even makes a lie angle recommendation. The T200 features Titleist's Max Impact Technology, which is meant to deliver faster ball speeds with better distance control and tighter shot dispersion. The difference in terms of difference with corresponding irons in these sets was almost negligible. Over the years, both brands have evolved to offer a host of golf equipment products. I notice that there is up to 2 degrees difference in loft between some of the 5-irons, and it shows in the launch angle and spin data. To minimize variables, all testers hit Bridgestone Tour B-X Golf Balls inside our dedicated Lab X testing facility located in Yorktown, Va. Cobra! Distance does not always equal performance. In other words, if you are confident with low irons, you could potentially eliminate the need for a 3 hybrid, and game a 5 wood instead. Tommy . I would have never tried that club without the fitters advice, I know strokes Gaines is a defined metric, but I am confused how something can be #1 in strokes gained but #10 is forgiveness? If you're considering new irons later this year, make sure you give each of these options due consideration to help your game-improvement. Player distance irons are pretty forgiving, especially if they have a hollow construction design and tungsten weighting. They are not as long as the Apex. The irons used for the 2020 best players' irons test are: Callaway Apex 19 Irons. Striking a premium ball with the i525 irons produces a sound that . They pack a lot of advanced features most of which are predicated on shot forgiveness. We want you to get the most out of your Some players have suggested they feel to much like game improvement irons, They arent the most forgiving player-distance irons, They launch high with relatively low spin, They can give you good distance control, even into the wind, You can lose a bit of feel with the shorter irons. These mid and long irons in these mid-handicap focused sets are packed with technology to help you get the ball in the air, without having that super wide sole. It is important to note that there can be a correlation between distance and backspin. It would have been great if you could also have included the last years winner in this and other most wanted tests. Great looking clubs we all can hit. From super game improvement irons for high handicappers to players irons for Professionals. The bullet points below should help clarify the difference between player distance irons and game improvement irons in terms of handicap range: Even though player distance irons arent as workable as blades, they do allow for a reasonable degree of shot shaping ability. Not suitable for the average ball striker, It is difficult to get airborne for the average golfer, Heel and toe tungsten in long to mid irons, Designed for increased control over your shot shape, Difficult for slow swingers and high handicappers to launch these irons, It helps you increase your swing and clubhead speed, Eliminates vibrations on off-center strikes, Only hybrids available instead of long irons, Lightweight design is not suitable for faster swinging players, The high launch may cause some players to lose distance, Tungsten toe weighting in the mid and long irons.